class="postmedia-article-topper__headline"> Colby Cosh: Why Alberta is being accused of gerrymandering > 자유게시판

본문 바로가기

class="postmedia-article-topper__headline"> Colby Cosh: W…

profile_image
Stephen
2026-11-17 16:56 2 0

본문

News consumers outside Alberta are probably vaguely aware that the "G" word is being tossed around a lot lately over here. I speak, of course, of gerrymandering — the ancient American habit of a governing party drawing election boundary maps to its own naked advantage. Alberta has just concluded an update of its provincial map that became procedurally complicated, and politically fraught, in a way that is very unfamiliar in Canada.

Is it gerrymandering? After an evening in which gerrymandering blew up in the faces of Republicans in several American states, it is worth turning to this question. The usual procedure for re-mapping in Canada is that an independent commission is put together, that commission draws up a new map that seems fair, and the government accepts it.

This went off the rails in Alberta this time, which is an appropriate subject of Dominion-wide attention and concern. And, well, even if you're in Alberta, it takes some work to understand what the hell happened.

The ordinary Electoral Boundaries Commission, put together in the usual way, gave a unanimous interim report to the legislature in October of 2025. This commission was chaired by King's Bench Justice Dallas Miller. The Miller commission, as we'll call it, had about six months to take feedback on its base map and fine-tune it for an 89-seat legislature, up from 87 on the old map.



Editor's Picks







Ted Morton: What happens next in Alberta depends on Ottawa






Colby Cosh: What Alberta conservatives can learn from their B.C. brethren



This involved a squeeze: Alberta's population had grown by 20 per cent, mostly in the cities, since the 87-seat map was drawn. The final map, like any Canadian electoral map, would have to balance voting power without creating impractically oversized ridings in the less-populated rural areas.


In the time between the interim and final report, there was a philosophical split within Miller's committee over the right way to do this. A final map, endorsed by the majority of the commission, was submitted that preserved cities mostly intact within their legal boundaries. But two members filed a minority report that splintered the cities freely, even wildly, into a multitude of "hybrid" ridings, offering the logic that a city and its surrounding countryside is usually one big intercirculating economic, demographic, and cultural unit. (This view wasn't, and isn't, popular in the cities themselves.)

The majority map would have been favourable to the New Democrats, given an election with a perfectly even overall vote split between the NDP(A) and the governing Conservatives. The minority's map, with its hybridized cities, would have been a little better for the UCP. Some Conservatives would say "fairer." Election reformers have been quick to point out that this seems like a tacit endorsement of proportional representation, and if the Conservatives want that, they should just introduce it. Score one for the nerds.

Anyway, Miller had observed in his committee's final report that the whole process would be easier if the legislature had allowed for 91 seats instead of 89, allowing for new members in the growing cities and for the preservation of large rural ridings. The UCP took advantage of this opening. Premier Danielle Smith smacked a big red RESET button, or at least one imagines her doing so, and she ran through legislation increasing the Alberta legislature to 91 seats.


Alberta Premier Danielle Smith. Brent Calver/Postmedia

Which, of course, required the hasty creation of a new independent advisory panel to re-do the Miller commission's work and draw a new 91-seat map. That panel was led by a retired Provincial Court judge, Brian O'Ferrall. The new O'Ferrall quasi-commission submitted its report to a legislature committee a couple of weeks ago, and its final-final report and map have just been made public.

Everybody with me so far? The O'Ferrall map appears to be a legitimate compromise — assuming compromise is desirable — between the majority and minority reports produced by the original Miller commission. Most of the minority's ideas for rural-urban hybrid ridings have been rejected, and most of the original majority map has been accepted wholesale.

But the O'Ferrall map does break apart the city of Lethbridge, which is a fortress of the Alberta left surrounded by hatted hordes of ranchland ultra-conservatives, and it does appear to favour the more conservative-voting parts of the city of Calgary. For the purely electoral analysis of the new map, I would refer you to Kyle Hutton, a UCP-hating map-software wizard who finds himself relieved that the O'Farrell map wasn't anywhere near as awful and overtly rigged as he expected. Because of urban growth, there is still some expected seat-count advantage left to the New Democrats in an election where the overall vote is split evenly.

To return to our original question: is this a true gerrymander? I am tempted to answer "Yes, but it's gerrymandering as a condiment, not an entrée." I would agree with the NDP that institutional norms have suffered some injury. We expect, generally, that an Electoral Boundaries Commission will be left do its job without partisan intervention, or the contrived assembling of a second commission. If governments do choose to intervene, as this one has, they need to imagine an opposition party coming to power someday and using the same advantages in the same way.

Miller's original commission bears some responsibility for the mess. The majority acknowledged that rural-urban hybrid ridings may become more necessary as Alberta grows faster than the legislature, and also acknowledged that the minority had a point about legal city boundaries not being sacred totems. The O'Farrell report suggests that a decent compromise was possible all along, but the Miller commission couldn't find unanimity. The authors of the unconventional "minority report" were playing with fire. (Perhaps new technology allows them to do such a thing on one desktop, rather than involving a couple hundred draughtsmen and bean-counters in a rogue mapping exercise.)

Which requires us to observe … that the new O'Farrell report comes with its own minority dissent (co-signed by the brilliant University of Alberta law professor Gerard Kennedy). Oh Lord no! In this case, the minority hasn't wandered off and generated its own alternative map. Their sub-report complains that the UCP government abused Miller's recommendation for a 91-seat legislature; Miller specifically asked for the southern part of the original majority map to be left as-is, and the O'Farrell map doesn't do that.

This raises procedural questions of law on top of possible constitutional ones concerning voter equality that were in the background anyway. See you in court? If so, when? This is probably a lot of inside baseball for Livesgp readers to swallow at one go, so we'll skip over the exciting subplot about how Elections Alberta is watching all of this with terror and grief and is not sure a year is enough to prepare for the next general election with the late-arriving map.





Colby Cosh

Colby Cosh is a National Post columnist and author of the NP Platformed newsletter. He is a 1993 graduate in history of the University of Alberta. He hails from Bon Accord, Alta., and has almost always had a recurring byline somewhere since serving as a cub reporter for the Sturgeon Gazette in 1985. He was a writer and editor at legendary/notorious Alberta Report magazine from 1993 until its demise in 2003. At Maclean's magazine, he was a finalist for the National Magazine Award as a columnist in 2014.
ccosh@postmedia.com




Comments
Join the Conversation

Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion. Please keep comments relevant and respectful. Comments may take up to an hour to appear on the site. You will receive an email if there is a reply to your comment, an update to a thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information.



Sign in or Sign up to Comment
You must be logged in to join the discussion.

Sign InSign Up


Check your inbox

















Read Next






NP Comment
Brian Lee Crowley: The battle for truth is the fight for the future of western civilization
How October 7 made me realize that I had failed to defend against the lies of the left, and failed our country in the process











NP Comment
David Kaufman: The woke counter-attack on Trump
The Trumpian backlash against DEI has been overtaken by blue-haired radicals with nose rings and keffiyehs






News
Guess who will pay for high-speed rail cost overruns?
Evidence from high-speed rail projects around the world suggests the ultimate cost for the Alto line will be considerably higher than estimated















NAVIGATE

Newsletters

News

Opinion

Longreads

Modern Life

Puzzmo

Comics

National Post Store



SERVICES

Contact Us

Advertise With Us

Manage My Subscription

FAQ



FROM OUR PARTNERS

Shopping

Travel

Car News and Reviews

Personal Health

Classifieds

Business Guide

Play For Ontario



LEGAL

Sitemap

Copyright & Licensing

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Community Guidelines

Cookie Policy




© Copyright 2026, Postmedia Network Inc.

All rights reserved.

댓글목록0

등록된 댓글이 없습니다.

댓글쓰기

적용하기
자동등록방지 숫자를 순서대로 입력하세요.
게시판 전체검색
상담신청